Register/ Login   
Submit Mobile RSS Java Script Feed  
Home Blogs Spotlight Videos Movies Cartoon Photos Submit Media Space  Feed Directory 
World |  National |  Science & Technology |  Sports |  Entertainment |  Business & Economy |  General |  Columnist


Published on 26-07-2008 In National
Viewed 240 times
Manmohan Singh enhances infamy to India and himself as a Sikh!
Written by
SamI

"DOOMED IF it’s aye and doomed if nay" was the predicament Manmohan Singh had put himself and Congress party in when he sought a confidence vote on July 22, even as he had ten months to go to complete five-year-term.

Even a political novice would see that this is the most inopportune time for ruling parties in India to go to polls. There is anti-incumbency angst in the air after four years of lack lustre performance, fuelled by double digit inflation and dwindling growth. With ‘economic reforms’ managing to create only islands of prosperity, in a sea of misery and penury, mass suicides of ruined farmers have become routine.

Singh took a big risk in convening the session exclusively on the issue of ‘India-specific’ draft safeguards agreement with International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA). On the surface, the gamble paid off. The United Progressive Alliance (UPA) won with a margin of 19 votes – 275 ayes, 256 nays and 10 no-shows. But, he has every reason to grieve the day; for, a monstrous price had to be paid for the triumph. The Prime Minister’s rather ‘clean’ image, earned in a lifetime, got shattered irreparably by accusations of corruption.

In his obsessive zeal to conclude the nuclear deal, he appeared to cut despicable back-room deals. The price of an Member of Parliament (MP) – both for a UPA member being ‘loyal’ and a National Democratic Alliance (NDA) member becoming a ‘rebel’ – skyrocketed and was put at about Rs25 crore ($ 6 million). The ‘lucrative’ coal ministry was offered to get the votes controlled by a notorious MP, convicted for being bribed too openly by an earlier Congress regime to stay in power.

The telecom department, where a pending deal would mean gigantic kickbacks, was offered to a greenhorn MP, daughter of an epitome of corruption and constituent party boss. As every vote counted, several MPs were temporarily released from prison, where were serving time after all their attempts to escape punishment for murders had been exhausted. Senile, ailing lawmakers in their deathbed were brought for the voting literally in mobile Intensive Care Units (ICUs).

It is no secret that MPs, belonging to whatever political outfit, dread early elections. The ‘investment’ in getting elected runs into crores of rupees and losing even a single day of the a five year ‘payback period’ is unwise!

Ramgopal Yadav, an MP of Samajwadi Party, which shifted alliance to UPA lately, put this candidly during the debate on the trust vote. Yadav reminded the members that 60 per cent of the sitting MPs do not have the chance of winning next election or even getting a party ticket. He warned, "That percentage will only rise... Therefore, I appeal to all MPs to let the government complete its term!"

Singh’s party ruined dependable friendships while earning potentially disastrous allies in the run up for the trust vote. A noted wheeler dealer struck a deal – reportedly to sack the finance and petroleum ministers who were not ‘friendly’ to a party financier, and the defence minister to make way for his party boss – in a wholesale deal of all party MPs.



He agreed to name the Lucknow airport after former PM Chowdhary Charan Singh, whose son was an ‘available’ MP. Charan Singh occupied the post for less than seven months and had an exactly opposite image and could not face Parliament even once.

It is already going to be a Herculean job to retain numbers in the next elections in the normal course. The party runs the risk of getting wiped out if elections are held earlier. Some of the other UPA constituents could cling on to power by shifting to a new coalition, but that is not an option before Congress. Failure to demonstrate a simple majority in this session could definitely have led to early elections. Advancing of elections is still a fair possibility, if the ‘deals’ made for winning are not ‘honoured’.

What made Singh’s move particularly incongruous was that it was entirely avoidable. Firstly, the risk of possible total rout was not accompanied by any commensurate rewards for securing a yes vote. There was no tearing urgency to go to IAEA, as there is only a dim possibility of the nuke deal being wrapped up before Bush demits office. The issue is most likely to be reviewed by any administration that succeeds him.

True, a positive makes India’s proposal to IAEA ’official’, so that the governing council of the United Nations (UN) watchdog may debate it at its next meeting on August 1. But then, even if an instant IAEA approval is managed, a separate agreement is necessary to be struck with Nuclear Suppliers Group (NSG), the countries that export nuclear material. Many NSG countries, with far more advanced nuclear technology than India’s, are critical of "a clear, clean and unconditional" NSG exemption India wants. Detractors object to clauses with ambiguous wording, which could limit international monitoring of New Delhi’s civilian facilities and lack of guarantees against fissile material going to weapons program. Only after NSG clearance can the deal go to US Congress.

More importantly, even if the deal does get the US seal of approval during the tenure of the UPA government – a very big if – it is unlikely to translate into any electoral advantage to Congress, irrespective of the timing of elections.

Secondly, Congress has always benefited from voters sympathetic to leftist views in every state. Although the Communists may not win on their own strength, they have definitely given the winning edge with seat adjustments. Squandering that could be suicidal. What is more, the comrades, whose formal withdrawal of ‘outside’ support triggered the crisis, are not known for shortsighted nationalist jingoism. Diverting scarce resources needed to ameliorate miseries of the masses to weapons development is not in their agenda. Their only objection was that the deal ties India too closely with the US. The leadership fears being perceived by cadres as ‘collaborators’ of US by appearing to oblige ‘President Bush!. Most Indian Marxists still live in a cold war time warp when US was the imperialist enemy of their ideals, China and Russia.

Thirdly, Bhartiya Janta Party (BJP), the Hindu nationalist outfit leading the opposition NDA, has explicitly declared it is not against a "very close relationship" with America. After all, the dialogue was actually initiated during NDA regime after it conducted nuke tests in 1998. There was no other option otherwise to lighten the crippling sanctions in the wake of the abandonment of ‘self-imposed’ 24-year moratorium on proliferation.

It is not that Indian politicians are eggheads, unable to understand realities on the ground. And Singh, who has never won an election in lifetime for enjoying top posts, apparently made the blunder of underestimating the Machiavellian calibre they are endowed with.

They are aware that roll back of India’s weapon program is imminent and is not conditional upon ‘sovereign’ decisions they take in their wisdom. The plight of Iran and North Korea, and Iraq earlier, which quiver under anti-proliferation pressures even after eschewing nuke weapons and signing Non Proliferation Treaty (NPT) is well known. It is also not lost on them that Indians are basically timid and not as fanatically committed to tribal sentiments.

Last of all, Indian lawmakers and administrators very well understand that multi-million dollar projects in the nuke sector will also mean multi-million dollar kickbacks! Being foreign money, they will not depend on the mingy Indian exchequer!

The only constituency in India that wages a ‘genuine’ fight against the opening up of nuclear power sector are the bosses and staff of dysfunctional nuclear establishments. They dread accountability as showing off flop shows as blue chips will end, like it happened in other sectors like telecom, aviation, and steel. But, Manmohan Singh must be the last man to bother about that, as he is already hated as the architect of economic reforms.

Surely, the grand victory, which will need to be terribly grieved by the party in the coming weeks, was not his exclusive faux pas. He only executed orders of his predecessor Rajiv Gandhi’s widow Sonia, due to whose magnanimity he is PM. She happens to be heading the dynastic outfit.

To wipe out the muck he has invited upon himself by doing her bidding, Manmohan Singh will do well to now do the bidding of the ‘original’ Gandhi, Mohandas Karamchand, who is celebrated as the ‘father of the nation’.

 Numerous Indians believe that he brought independence to the country from the British, who actually had decided to quit anyway! What the congress patriarch did was to expedite transfer of power – to the Nehru dynasty from colonial masters! The family has even appropriated the Gandhi tag! While Sonia Gandhi is the chief of the party, her son is being projected as the future PM!

The ‘original’ Gandhi apparently predicted the turn of events, months before he was assassinated in 1948. He advocated dissolution of the party to prevent the occurrence of the sordid scene being witnessed today.

Prime Minister Singh can earn a place in history by fulfilling that wish now. In a way, it will be the best thing he will have done for the Sikh community also, which can hardly forgive the dynasty!

 
 0 Comments     Share   Blog     Print
 

 No Comments
Add Your Comment

Join Indiainteracts for free to comment on this story. Have an account already? Login to comment










     

Durai...

Rasikkum Seemane ...

Mahesh Saranya Mat...


Kanagavel Kakka...

Saroja...

Dhanam...

Durai Audio Launch ...

Saroja Promo songs ...

Aatta Nayagan movi ...


Homam trailer ...

Harshini Ramani ...

Ganesha speaks Ast ...
     


About | Content providers | Support | Beta feedback | Report abuse | Contact us | Careers | FAQ